European
officials say plan amounts to a take-it-or-leave-it offer to unlock much-needed
aid for Athens
The Wall
Street Journal
By MARCUS
WALKER
Updated
June 2, 2015 4:39 p.m. ET
The plan
marks a sharp shift in tactics by Germany ,
the IMF and other Greek creditors, who have lost patience with what they see as
months of fruitless dialogue with the Athens
government. Lenders drafted the proposed deal after key leaders, including
German Chancellor Angela Merkel, met in Berlin
late Monday to overcome their own divisions on how to keep Greece from bankruptcy and an exit
from the euro.
European
officials say Greek officials, which are expected to be shown the creditors’
proposal Wednesday, will now be asked to accept the terms with, at most, minor
changes. Greek Premier Alexis Tsipras is slated to visit European Commission
head Jean-Claude Juncker the same day in Brussels ,
where the lenders’ demands as well as Greece ’s conflicting ideas are
likely to be discussed.
But the
policy conditions in the creditors’ proposal—whose details remained under wraps
but include fiscal austerity, privatizations, and overhauls of pensions and
labor law—could prove extremely challenging for Mr. Tsipras to accept without
sparking a rebellion within his ruling coalition.
European
policy makers are trying hard to avoid the appearance of an ultimatum to Greece , knowing that this would make an
already-difficult deal even harder for Athens
to swallow. Most European officials were tight-lipped about the lenders’ latest
initiative. But some officials admitted Tuesday that the move amounted to a
take-it-or-leave-it offer to Greece .
Led by the
German chancellery, creditors have been moving toward this tactic over the past
two weeks, after growing frustrated with the lack of progress in negotiations
with Greek officials aimed at a compromise.
Lenders now
hope that Mr. Tsipras can be pressed to accept the creditors’ outline of a deal
by the end of this week—allowing lower-level officials to complete the details
next week, European officials say. That would allow the European Central Bank
to make more liquidity available to Greek banks, allowing them to buy more
short-term debt from the Greek government and relieving some of the immediate
financial pressure.
Mr. Tsipras
faces particularly tough days and weeks ahead since Monday night’s summit in Berlin resulted in a consensus among creditors that
leaves Greece
will little scope to fulfill Syriza’s election promises.
Greek
officials had until now often cited disagreements among the creditors
themselves as a big reason for the deadlock in bailout negotiations. But in Berlin , the IMF and the eurozone bridged their
differences by agreeing that Athens must be made
to enact comprehensive economic overhauls, as the IMF wanted—yet that there
would be no explicit commitment, for now, to forgive some of Greece ’s debt. Germany and other eurozone governments have
strongly resisted IMF pressure to offer Greece debt relief that would
impose losses on other European taxpayers.
The
combination of tough economic measures and a delay to any potential debt relief
could test the unity of Mr. Tsipras’s governing coalition. With a majority of
only 12 in Greece ’s
300-seat parliament, even a small rebellion by some of Syriza’s hard-line left
factions could deprive Mr. Tsipras of crucial support, forcing him to rely on
opposition votes and potentially triggering elections or a referendum. Some
Syriza lawmakers are already calling for new elections rather than what they
see as surrender to creditors’ terms.
“In terms
of packaging this deal, Tsipras doesn’t have any easy way to sell it to his
party,” said Wolf Piccoli, director of research at political risk consultancy
Teneo Intelligence. “If Tsipras feels he might lose his parliamentary majority,
he might pass the vote to the public.”
The
proposed deal would complete Greece ’s
current bailout program with its eurozone partners, a process that some
officials say could extend over this summer. By fall, officials say, Greece will
need a new bailout package that keeps the country afloat until it is able to
access international bond markets again—which many economists say could take
years.
Ms. Merkel
and other eurozone leaders are eager to avoid a default by Greece on its
debt that could lead to the country tumbling out of the euro. But Ms. Merkel
needs Mr. Tsipras to accept tough fiscal discipline and broader economic
overhauls if she is to sell further aid loans for Greece
to a German parliament and public that is increasingly skeptical about Greece ’s
willingness to make its economy as lean and competitive as euro membership
requires.
Ever since Greece ’s international bailout began in 2010,
Ms. Merkel has made the IMF the arbiter of whether Greece is enacting enough austerity
and overhauls to deserve aid loans. The IMF remains Germany ’s
ally on Greek overhauls, in the face of reluctance elsewhere in
Europe—including at the Brussels-based European Commission—to impose drastic
and politically difficult policy overhauls on Athens . But the Washington-based fund has
clashed with Berlin
over Greek’s huge debt.
The IMF insists
Greece
can be rendered solvent only through either far-reaching economic overhauls, or
through debt forgiveness. Germany
has so far staunchly rejected writing off its aid loans to Greece .
Late on
Monday, the creditors overcame their differences by agreeing that Greece must enact comprehensive overhauls to
earn fresh financing, while the IMF softened its insistence that Europe offer explicit commitments on debt relief.
In a show
of defiance, Mr. Tsipras told reporters that Athens has submitted its own proposed terms
for a deal to European institutions and the IMF. Mr. Tsipras said he was
optimistic that Greece ’s
proposal would be accepted. But European officials said that Greece ’s own
proposals remain insufficiently comprehensive or specific—a problem that has
frustrated creditors for weeks, and that led to this week’s take-it-or-leave-it
initiative.
Mr. Tsipras
said he believes European leaders will be “realistic” and accept the Greek
counterproposal. “The decision now lies with the political leadership in Europe [to reach an agreement],” Mr. Tsipras said. “We
don’t expect any other plan to be submitted; Greece is the one submitting the
plan,” the Greek premier said.
The ECB on
Tuesday increased the amount of liquidity that Greek banks can borrow under an
emergency liquidity program to €80.7 billion ($89 billion) from €80.2 billion
previously, according to a Greek bank official. The increase preserves the
financial buffer that Greek banks have to cope with steady deposit outflows,
which reflect months of uncertainty over Greece ’s bailout.
Syriza’s
parliamentary spokesman Nikos Filis said on local television that Greece won’t accept an ultimatum from creditors,
and that Greece ’s
government cannot sign an agreement that is incompatible with the party’s
antiausterity program.
“If we are
talking about an ultimatum…which isn’t within the framework of the popular
mandate, it is obvious that the government cannot co-sign and accept it,” Mr.
Filis said. Mr. Filis said that if 12 or more Syriza lawmakers vote against the
proposed deal, wiping out the ruling coalition’s majority, then Greece should
hold new elections.
—Nektaria
Stamouli contributed to this article.
Write to
Marcus Walker at marcus.walker@wsj.com
No comments:
Post a Comment